Summary of Legal Outcomes

Over a six-year period, multiple legal proceedings were initiated by the same parties against Dr Naomi Pty Ltd and Dr Naomi McCullum
The outcomes are summarised below.


Record of Proceedings


Dr Stephen Crimston & Cosmedocs Pty Ltd v Britmed Pty Ltd (formerly Dr Naomi Pty Ltd)

District Court of New South Wales – 2021/00172553
Filed: 16 June 2021

Judgment – 5 August 2026

  1. Judgment for Britmed Pty Ltd (formerly Dr Naomi Pty Ltd).
  2. The Further Amended Statement of Claim filed on 27 February 2026 was dismissed.

READ THE JUDGMENT

Costs Judgment – 20 October 2026

The Court ordered:

“(1) The plaintiffs are to pay the defendant’s costs of these proceedings on an indemnity basis, except for the costs the subject of the order of 30 January 2026 and the costs the subject of the order made by consent on 9 October 2026.”

READ THE COSTS JUDGMENT

 


Dr Stephen Crimston v Dr Naomi Pty Ltd & Dr Naomi McCullum
Fair Work Commission – C2021/2306
Filed: 22 April 2021
Outcome: Discontinued by Dr Stephen Crimston (2 May 2021)


Dr Stephen Crimston v Dr Naomi Pty Ltd & Dr Naomi McCullum
Fair Work Commission – C2020/7321
Filed: 28 September 2020
Outcome: Discontinued by Dr Stephen Crimston (12 April 2021)


Dr Elsa Sophia Delport v Dr Naomi Pty Ltd
Applicant: Dr Elsa Sophia Delport (registered as Dr Elsie Delport, AHPRA)
District Court of New South Wales – 2022/00256920
Filed: 29 August 2022
Outcome: Discontinued Feb 2025
Dr Elsa Sophia Delport to pay Dr Naomi’s legal costs.


Dr Elsa Delport v Dr Naomi Pty Ltd & Dr Naomi McCullum
Applicant: Dr Elsa Delport (registered as Dr Elsie Delport, AHPRA)
Fair Work Commission – C2021/2317
Filed: 23 April 2021
Outcome: Discontinued by Dr Elsa Delport (2 May 2021)


Dr Elsa Delport v Dr Naomi Pty Ltd & Dr Naomi McCullum
Applicant: Dr Elsa Delport (registered as Dr Elsie Delport, AHPRA)
Fair Work Commission – C2020/7308
Filed: 25 September 2020
Outcome: Discontinued by Dr Elsa Delport (12 April 2021)


Dr Joseph Waelchli v Dr Naomi Pty Ltd & Dr Naomi McCullum
Fair Work Commission – C2020/7958
Filed: 26 October 2020
Outcome: Discontinued by Dr Joseph Waelchli (11 February 2021)

 

Supporting documents are available on request. Please email info@themanseclinic.com.au for further information